The explosive report carried by the Indian Express on September 23, 2026, raises the most profound questions about the legitimacy of the Special Intensive Review (SIR) carried out by the Election Commission and the charade the electoral process has been reduced to in general.
The Indian Express report brings to light the following:
Two election commissioners, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, out of a total three members registered 14 formal objections over a period of 10 months on various aspects of the SIR process.
Decisions regarding voter deletions or additions in the electoral rolls were taken without Sandhu’s or Joshi’s knowledge or approval.
Sandhu and Joshi termed the changes to the Form-6 “unauthorised” and “illegal” and called for their immediate removal.
The Electoral Registration Officers (EROs), who are legally responsible for preparing and maintaining electoral rolls, had their access to the electoral rolls restricted by the centralised IT division. Thus, those who are statutorily mandated to be able to make changes to electoral rolls did not have access to them, and the two sitting election commissioners were unaware of additions and deletions to the electoral rolls. In Goa, 97 voters whom local authorities had found eligible could not be restored to the rolls because the necessary functionality was unavailable in the software.
These revelations acquire their full significance when placed against the scale of the ongoing SIR. The exercise has already resulted in more than 13 crore names being struck from draft electoral rolls across 30 States and Union Territories and has placed India at the precipice of the gravest constitutional and democratic crisis that it has ever faced in its independent history. The investigation confirms the suspicions voiced by numerous political and civil rights activists about the institutional structure through which India’s electorate is constituted: whether statutory powers vested in Electoral Registration Officers are being increasingly centralised through the ECI’s technological infrastructure; whether statutory forms can be altered without the procedure prescribed by law; and, most fundamentally, whether decisions affecting citizens’ access to the franchise are being made with the transparency, legal authority and institutional accountability that such decisions require.
The fascist BJP only wants to keep the shell of democracy intact while hollowing it out of its substance from the inside. They want the legitimacy that an electoral process accords, without any accountability towards the electorate or the minimal procedural requirements that a democratic process entails.
The RCPI demands:
Immediate removal of Gyanesh Kumar as Chief Election Commissioner (CEC).
Immediate suspension of the SIR process, and restoration of wrongfully deleted names from the electoral roll.
Cancellation of elections in all seats where SIR deletion is greater than margin of victory, across India.
A constitutional reform of the appointment and selection process for Election Commissioners, ensuring that the Election Commission is composed of persons who can exercise their constitutional responsibilities independently, impartially, and free from executive or political influence.
We call upon the workers, peasants and the youth of the country to take to the streets to reclaim democracy.